On my October 5th blog I suggested that the Nikkei was in good shape for a rally. The Nikkei had just broken out of a “Phase 1” consolidation (see my book Sideways), proving that the former downtrend had ended. The index sat in the mid 16,000’s at the time.
At ValueTrend, we played the breakout via an ETF – and noted that ETF as a Top Pick on my BNN appearance that month. Currently, the Nikkei is facing the potential of an overbought selloff. Its approaching the 19,000 level – a 15% rise in just 2 months from that breakout. As noted in my original blog – the Nikkei is influenced by the Yen. There is a negative correlation between the Yen/USD and the performance of the Nikkei. Thus, when the Yen stops falling, the Nikkei may stop rising. Note the negative correlation on the bottom pane (correlation study) of the chart below. You can visually note the negative correlation by comparing the red line (Yen/USD) to the Nikkei itself – which is the black line. They have moved in opposite directions much of the time.
At this time, the Yen looks like it may be ready to find support at an old low. Further, it is significantly oversold—in stark contrast to the Nikkei, which is quite overbought. Note the divergence in the momentum studies shown on the Yen chart below. They have been rising in the face of a flattening pattern for the Yen. Again—what’s good for the Yen is bad for the Nikkei – as a general rule. I’m also concerned by the fact that I noticed a couple of ETF orientated Portfolio Managers only now jumping on the Japan bandwagon. Sentimentrader.com tends to put ETF flow into the category of “dumb money”- that is, money that is often late in the game. This may by itself be a contrarian sell signal–it’s too late when the trade becomes crowded. The only balancing factor that I can see for further Yen weakness is a greater than expected rate hike by the Fed later this week. The Yen has built in a rate hike, but a bigger one than expected will push it down through the support and pressure it against an oversold rally.
I’m willing to take my chances on this weeks Fed meeting not being too much of a surprise – which should strengthen the Yen. Further, there is an approaching period of relative seasonal weakness for the Nikkei from early January to mid-March -see equityclock’s chart below. I just sold out of my Japanese ETF position that I bought back in the fall. If you own some Nikkei orientated ETF’s, you might want to consider your options on this position. While the Japanese market may be good over a longer period, I question the continuation of this rally in the near-term.
Thanks for the pertinent review of the Japanese stock market. I added to my CJP position when you recommended it on BNN. I’m obviously happy with the results. Please help me understand something if possible. I was already holding a position in the Nikkei through the US Dollar denominated EWJ. I noticed that the CJP lagged the EWJ for most of the year but there is a notable out-performance of my CJP versus my EWJ starting in early November. I looked at the sector and securities differences briefly and I am not sure that they are distinct or large enough to account solely for the recent out-performance of the CJP. The question I have is: what was the influence of the Canadian Dollar and the Canadian Dollar hedge in this November spike?
As always, many thanks for your comments.
EWJ does not hedge the Yen movement. The problem of late has been a strong bearish trend for the Yen while the Nikkei rises. So you get cancellation by the Yens downside on the Nikkei’s upside via EWJ. CJP on the other hand is currency hedged. That has a cost, but a worthwhile cost in light of the recent trends on the Yen. So that’s why – especially lately–the CJP units were the best horse in the race.