Bearish sentiment prevails on the stock market, which has driven money into the bond market. Things are getting rather overbought on both Canadian and US bond markets –as illustrated by the XBB iShares Canadian Bond ETF, and the TLT US long bond ETF. Note the overbought momentum studies (stochastics, RSI, MACD), and the parabolic rise on the chart of late. While we don’t see the indicators rounding over at this moment, it might make sense that we’ll see this excess washed out in the coming days or weeks. Such a movement – especially on bonds – is unusual – and unsustainable for the longer term.
Bonds becoming overbought, stocks becoming oversold
Jason Goepfert of sentimentrader.com notes that the stock/bond ratio is showing a likelihood for the bond market losing ground and stock market gaining in the coming weeks.
He also notes that the AAII survey of individual investors suggests retail investors (dumb money) are becoming very bearish after the recent 6% market decline. When retail investors become this bearish on stocks after a relatively small decline (as we have now), markets typically follow through with a bit more downside in the following weeks. But…after that, stocks almost always finish stronger a month later.
Putting these two indicators together (charts courtesy www.sentimentrader.com), it might make sense that we get a little more downside (possibly to my 2600 target) in the near-term. But, this could be followed by strength into late June. The end of June is significant – not just from Jason’s statistics. It’s also the date of the G20 summit. I might suggest that the US/China rhetoric may turn a bit more positive as they head towards that summit. There’s nothing like sending nasty tweets out a week before you have to meet with the guy you’ve been tweeting about. Talk about embarrassing!
Who knows…there may be some plausible market relief coming if both parties begin to sound more positive as they come closer to the summit. And that might just coincidently line up with Jason’s observations of market rallying a month after the signals discussed above. Just thinking out loud here….
Back to Jason’s work. For those interested, here is his explanation of how the stock/bond ratio is constructed and interpreted:
There are any number of ways to monitor the relationship between the two, but the best we have found is a simple ratio between the S&P 500 and the yield on 10-year Treasury Notes.
This indicator measures the ratio between these two indexes, then transforms it into an expression which shows how extreme it is compared to other recent readings. What we’re looking for are the real extremes – when stocks become “overvalued” relative to bonds, then we often see stocks decline and bonds rise. When stocks become “undervalued” according to the ratio, then stocks typically rise while bonds fall (i.e. yields rise).
Our stock/bond ratio will rarely get above +3 or below -3. Basically, a reading of +3 means that stocks are so overvalued that we see a more extreme reading only about 1% of the time – very unusual. When the ratio hits -3, it suggests that stocks are deeply undervalued relative to bonds, and we rarely see a more extreme condition.
As noted above, when the ratio becomes very high, then we should expect stocks to fall and/or bonds to rise. When the ratio is very low, then we look for stocks to rally and/or bonds to fall in value.
So bond funds (TLT) are overbought. Held at over $130 for 2 days now. Should us TLT holders wait for another day, and if it holds or takes another shot up, then sell?
Hard to say Tom–it could carry on higher – but odds are not much higher–I’d be inclined to make hay while the sun shines now-given how overbought it is-but that’s not necessarily the best thing to do–its just the way I would do it.
Hi Keith, a quick question not pertaining to bonds but to how much cash to accumulate in these downturns, over the last 4 weeks decided to lock in some profits by selling and went from a 75/25 split to a 55/45, just wondering if you have any rules that you follow for this. Thanks Anthony
Actually, we do have a few guidelines (not hard rules) for cash. We base it on trend, and the level of our Bear-o-meter. Below are the guidelines. Note that a “4” Bear-o-meter reading suggests 0-10% cash. Clearly if the trend is good, we go near 0% cash. If its looking less attractive , we go 10% cash. It should be noted that it would be highly unlikely for a Bear-o-meter reading of 4 if the trend was decidedly down. That’s because it gets a positive or negative rating of “2” just for the markets position above or below the 200 day SMA.
0 = 75% cash
1 = 40% – 50% cash
2 = 20% – 40% cash
3 = 15% – 20% cash
4 = 0% -10% cash
5 = 0% – 10% cash
6 = 0% cash
7 = 0% cash higher beta
8 = 0% cash very high beta
Hi Keith, thank you for your response, hope your on the mend and look forward to the 20th.
Thanks for the advice Keith. I hope everything is ok with you. I see you missed Market Call last evening
Fell on bike on Saturday–strained lots of ligaments/ bruises and a minor crack in the pelvic bone (hairline–not too serious)– temporarily hoping around on crutches–I will be fine (I do 15,000 km/ year on a bike and have done so for 20 years–so that’s 300,000km without a crash–guess I was due one). Anyhow, no riding for now, no racing for a few months – but Dr. told me it’ll heal on its own with a bit of R&R. Had to cancel BNN, and also a podcast interview I was going to be featured in –but both were re-booked for April 20th.
Looks like it’s time to get back into the market
If 2800 is taken out on the SPX for a few days – that would confirm the legitimacy of this move.
Oh no. I sure hope youre feeling a bit better now. Please take are of yourself